So I have game?...?...?

While I don't TRY to get girls I often see them staring at me in the hall... At first I'm just thinking, "Oh my GOD... what do I have on my face!!!" but then I talk to a girl and they say girls find me legitimately attractive... as soon as I heard this I felt like I was superman... but then she told me which girls like me and while there were some DEADLY pretty girls on that list, most of it was comprised of ugly fat girls... Any advice on how I could get the "stay and plays" and lose the "throw aways"?